Learn how NIH identifies grant applications for funding recommendations.
Why NIH Uses Two Levels of Review
NIH uses a two-level review system that is mandated by statute and strictly regulated. In the first level, multiple scientific experts independently evaluate the scientific and technical merit of applications and then discuss them as a review panel. In the second level, the results of this scientific evaluation are considered along with programmatic priorities in developing funding recommendations The separation of scientific evaluation from funding recommendations is designed to promote fairness in peer review. Reviewers cannot serve in both levels of peer review in the same review cycle. Dedicated NIH staff with distinct roles and responsibilities manage each level of the process.
Who Does What?
Scientific review officers (SROs) and program officers (POs) have distinct roles. The SRO manages the first level of peer review, while the PO advises applicants on scientific fit at the funding IC and program priorities, manages IC grant portfolios, and provides guidance before and after review. This separation is by design, preserving the independence of scientific review while ensuring applicants receive appropriate programmatic guidance.
Contact your SRO with questions about peer review, review policies, or review logistics.
Contact your PO with questions about IC scientific fit, program priorities, application preparation, funding, or review outcomes and next steps.