Second Level: Advisory Council Review

Scope Note

National Advisory Councils or Boards perform the second level of peer review for research grant applications and offer advice and recommendations on policy and program development, program implementation, evaluation, and other matters of significance to the mission and goals of the respective Institutes or Centers (ICs). 

Who Reviews the Application?

The Advisory Council/Board of the potential awarding Institute/Center performs the second level of review (See List of NIH Advisory Committees page). Advisory Councils/Boards are composed of scientists from the extramural research community and public representatives (NIH Federal Advisory Committee Information). Members are chosen by the respective IC and are approved by the Department of Health and Human Services. For certain committees, members are appointed by the President of the United States.

Recommendation Process

NIH program staff members examine applications and consider the overall impact scores given during the peer review process, percentile rankings (if applicable) and the summary statements in light of the Institute/Center's priorities.

Program staff provide a grant-funding plan to the Advisory Board/Council. Council members have access to applications and summary statements pending funding for that IC in that council round.

Council members conduct a Special Council Review of grant applications from investigators who currently receive $2 million or more in total costs (inclusive of direct and indirect) of NIH funding to support Research Project Grants pr year (see NOT-OD-22-049 and NOT-OD-12-140). This additional review is to determine if additional funds should be provided to already well-supported investigators and does not represent a cap on NIH funding.

The Advisory Council/Board also considers the Institute/Center’s goals and needs and advises the Institute/Center director concerning funding decisions.

Note
The Institute or Center director makes final Funding Decisions based on staff and Advisory Council/Board advice.

Resources

Upcoming Events

    Videos

      Contact

      Need help with...Contact
      Institute/Center application assignment or referralCSR Division of Receipt and Referral (DRR) staff at [email protected]
      Peer review, review policies, or review logisticsAssigned scientific review officer (SRO) - contact information available in eRA Commons after application submission
      IC scientific fit, program priorities, application preparation, funding, or review outcomes and next stepsAssigned program official (PO) - contact information available in eRA Commons after application submission or in the Summary Statement after application review 

      This page last updated on: November 16, 2026
      For technical issues E-mail OER Webmaster