Learn what happens once your application is received by NIH, including how we determine which study section it will go to for peer review and how we assign it to an NIH institute, center, or office for funding consideration.
Get a High-level Understanding of the Receipt and Referral Process
All grant applications submitted to NIH go to the Division of Receipt and Referral (DRR) within the Center for Scientific Review (CSR).
After receiving an application, DRR
- Checks the application for completeness
- Assigns an application identification number
- Assigns the applications to a scientific review group (study section) for first-level peer review
- Assigns the application to a funding instute or center for the second level of review for funding consideration
Applicants can use eRA Commons to
- Retrieve assignment information
- Find contact information for the assigned program and scientific review officers
- Find review meeting and council meeting dates
- Withdraw your application from consideration
DRR Appeal Policy
DRR seeks to apply NIH policies regarding the receipt and referral of grant applications fairly. We expect applicants to be aware of published NIH policies, and we expect our implementation of policies and procedures to be consistent, reasonable, and transparent. In line with these expectations, it is sometimes necessary for DRR to administratively withdraw applications from consideration.
Procedures to appeal DRR's withdrawal of a grant application:
- If you disagree with DRR’s decision to withdraw your application, we encourage you to first contact the person who made the decision to better understand the basis of the withdrawal.
- If, following the conversation with the DRR official who made the withdrawal decision, the program director (PD)/principal investigator (PI) still wants to initiate an appeal, the individual must do so within one week of the initial withdrawal notice.
- Appeal by contacting DRR leadership. Provide a letter that explains the issues and why the action should be reversed. The DRR Director will consider the information you provide and re-examine the facts, policy, and initial decision. If the DRR Director agrees with you, the action will be reversed. If not, the Director will provide you with an explanation of why the decision should stand.
- If the original DRR decision is upheld, and you continue to believe it is wrong, you may contact the Director of CSR. The Office of the Director will review the case again, either internally or by sending it to CSR’s Arbitration Board. This board is a trans-NIH group of senior-level staff charged with considering appeals carefully and in context. You will receive a prompt response to your concerns.
- Once an appeal is initiated, the PD/PI is expected to respond promptly (not later than one week) to all future correspondence related to the matter.
Dig Deeper into Study Sections
Grant applications are assigned to study sections (also referred to as scientific review groups or SRGs) for peer review by scientific experts. Study sections are clustered within review branches, based on scientific discipline.
Recommend a Study Section
NIH encourages you to submit an Assignment Request Form with your application. The form allows you to:
- Express a preference for a particular study section
- Express a preference for a specific awarding component (an NIH Institute or Center)
- Let us know of potential reviewers who you feel might have a conflict of interest with your application
- Describe the expertise needed to review your application; do not provide names
Review Meetings
Request Reassignment
For questions about the appropriateness of the study section, the investigator should contact the scientific review officer. Contact information for the scientific review officer can be found in your eRA Commons account.
Requests to change the assigned funding institute/center are best addressed in a scientific dialogue between the PD/PI and program official at their desired institute/center. If the PD/PI has not identified a program official, alternately they may send a scientific rationale to the Division of Receipt and Referral at [email protected].
When the review location, primary or dual institute, or timetable for consideration (advisory council round) is changed for an application, the information will be updated in eRA Commons.