NIH identifies and manages potential conflicts of interest in peer review to protect the fairness and impartiality of the process. The guidance below explains how conflicts are managed and gives examples for NIH grant and contract reviews.
Why Does NIH Manage Conflicts of Interest (COI)?
A conflict of interest (COI) exists when a financial interest, professional or personal relationship, or other circumstance could affect a reviewer's impartiality or create the appearance to a reasonable person that the reviewer may not be impartial. NIH identifies and manages potential COIs to protect the fairness and impartiality of peer review.
How Are Conflicts Managed During Peer Review?
Before participating in peer review, reviewers identify and disclose potential conflicts of interest involving the applications or proposals, investigators, and institutions being reviewed. Scientific review officers (SRO) review potential conflicts and determine how they should be managed. Reviewers certify their COIs before and after the meeting.
How a COI is managed depends on the nature of the conflict and type of review:
- Out of meeting COI: A reviewer cannot serve as reviewer on the study section. In contract review all COI are out of meeting COI.
- Out of the room COI: The reviewer can serve on the study section and participate in the meeting but cannot access, review, discuss, or score an application for which they have a COI and is not present when it is discussed.
If a reviewer has a question about a potential conflict or their ability to remain objective, they should discuss it with the SRO. It is important that COIs are identified and disclosed to the SRO as early in the review process as possible.
What Is and Is Not Considered a COI?
COIs can arise from financial interests, employment, professional or personal relationships, institutional affiliations, and other circumstances. Because standing study section members serve together regularly, an application from one of its members must be reviewed by a different study section to maintain the objectivity of the review.
Below are common situations that are and are not considered COIs in grant versus contract reviews. For the purposes of COI determination “the reviewer” includes the reviewer’s close family members.
Common COIs for NIH Research Grant Review
Out of the meeting COI
A reviewer cannot serve as a reviewer on the study section if:
- The reviewer is listed on the application in a major professional role.
- The reviewer is a member of an NIH Advisory Council.
- The reviewer would receive a direct financial benefit if the application is funded.
Out of the room COI
A reviewer may participate in the meeting but cannot review or participate in the discussion of a specific application if:
- The reviewer has indirect financial interest of more than $10,000 (e.g., honoraria, stocks and fees during the last year).
- The reviewer is from the same institution (or institutional component) as the Principal Investigator (PI) or another person with a major role on the application. This includes secondary appointments at institutions involved in the application.
- The reviewer has been in a professional relationship (e.g., collaboration, publication, or grant submission) within the past 3 years with someone on the application who has a major role.
- The reviewer had a trainee/advisor relationship within the past 10 years.
- The reviewer included a letter of support or reference letter for an application.
- The reviewer is serving as a member of the advisory board for the project under review.
- The reviewer is interviewing or has recently interviewed at the institution(s) of the PI or other key persons with a major role on the application.
Note
Although it is best to verify with the SRO, the following are generally not considered a COI in research project review.
- Co-authorship on a non-research publication (such as review, commentary, or conference report) or on a mega-multi-authored publication.
- Membership in the same research network that involves a person with a major role on the proposed project.
- Contribution of data, reagents, specimens, etc., to the same repository or database.
- Working in the same scientific area.
Common COIs for NIH Contract Reviews
Out of the meeting COI
A reviewer cannot serve on the technical evaluation study section if:
- The reviewer is named on the proposal in a major professional role.
- The reviewer (or close family member) would receive a direct financial interest if the proposal is funded.
- The reviewer is employed by the offerer institution.
- The reviewer is from an institution that is included as a subcomponent of the proposal.
- Within the past three years, the reviewer has been a collaborator or has been involved in the preparation of a grant application or contract proposal with, or has had any other professional relationship (e.g., served as a mentor) with any person on the proposal who has a major role.
- The proposal includes a letter of support or reference letter from the reviewer.
- The reviewer serves as a member of the advisory board for the project under review.
- The reviewer has an indirect financial interest from the offerer institution or person with a major professional role of over $10,000 in honoraria, stocks, and fees during the course of the last year or during the contract period.
For contract review, the following situations are not considered COI and the reviewer may serve on the study section:
- A proposal originates from an institution where the reviewer has collaborators, but the reviewer's collaborators are not listed on the proposal.
- The reviewer has an indirect financial interest of less than $10,000.
- The reviewer freely donates reagents or other materials to the proposed project, and these reagents or materials would also be available to other researchers.
- The reviewer, as well as a person with a major role on the proposed project, contributes data, reagents, specimens, etc., to the same repository or database.
- The reviewer is a member of a research network that involves a person with a major role on the proposed project.
- The reviewer is a co-author of a non-research publication (e.g., review, commentary) or a mega-multi-authored publication with a person with a major role on the proposed project.