Know Assignment Role

 
NIH peer reviewers may have different responsibilities at review meetings depending on their roles. Please check with your SRO.

 

Primary/Reviewer 1, Secondary/Reviewer 2 and Tertiary/Reviewer 3 (sometimes also designated as Discussant):

  • Review your assigned applications
  • Write and submit critiques and scores for assigned applications
  • Read critiques form other assigned reviewers
  • Be prepared to discuss the score driving strengths and weaknesses

Discussant

  • Read and understand the critiques of the assigned applications
  • Provide a short written review if the SRO asks for one

Mail-In Reviewer

  • Check with your SRO
  • Provide a written critique for the applications assigned and maybe submit preliminary criterion and/or impact scores.

Chair

  • Review the abstract and aims of all applications, and discuss any issues or changes in review policy/guidelines with the SRO
  • Write critiques and submit scores for the specific applications assigned to them (can be Reviewer 1, 2 or 3 for any given assignment)
  • Follow up on any other chair-specific instructions provided by the SRO

Resources