Reminder and Clarification of NIH Policies on Similar, Identical, or Essentially Identical Applications, Submission of Applications Following RFA Review, and Submission of Applications with a Changed Activity Code

Notice Number: NOT-OD-09-100

Update: The following update relating to this announcement has been issued:

Key Dates
Release Date: May 15, 2009

Issued by
National Institutes of Health (NIH), (http://www.nih.gov)

Purpose

The NIH and Public Health Service have had long-standing policies not to review the same or very similar application more than once.  These policies are of particularly timely importance due to the recent large number of applications submitted for FOAs under the Recovery Act, particularly those for RFA-OD-09-003, NIH Challenge Grants in Health and Science Research (RC1), and the potential large number of unfunded applications expected under this and other RFAs. There are many reasons for this policy, particularly the need to avoid added burdens on the review system, as well as on principal investigators and their institutions. 

The purposes of this Guide Notice are: 1) to remind Project Directors, Principal Investigators (PD/PIs) and applicant institutions that submissions of identical applications to one or more components of NIH or the Public Health Service are not allowed (http://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/notice-files/not99-146.html); 2) to clarify that NIH will not review any new or resubmission applications containing one or more of the specific aims contained in a similar, identical, or essentially identical application until after the peer review process for the original application has been completed and a summary statement has been provided to the PD/PI(s); 3) to remind the community of existing NIH policy on resubmitting unfunded RFA applications and applications with a changed grant activity code (http://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/notice-files/NOT-OD-03-019.html); and 4) to clarify that the application must be modified appropriately to fit the application requirements of the new FOA or activity code.  Applicant institutions are expected to take responsibility to ensure that applications submitted adhere to all of these policies and requirements. 

Non-compliant applications identified by NIH at any stage of the process (referral, peer review, program management, and/or grants management) will be withdrawn from funding consideration.

Policies

Submissions of Similar, Essentially Identical, or Identical Applications

Submission of identical applications to one or more components of the PHS is not allowed.  The NIH will not accept similar grant applications with essentially the same research focus from the same applicant organization. This includes derivative or multiple applications that propose to develop a single product, process, or service that, with non-substantive modifications, can be applied to a variety of purposes.  Likewise, identical or essentially identical grant applications submitted by different applicant organizations will not be accepted. 

Applicant organizations should ascertain and assure that the materials they are submitting on behalf of the PD/PI are the original work of the PD/PI and have not been used elsewhere in the preparation and submission of a similar grant application.  Applications to the NIH are grouped by scientific discipline for review by individual Scientific Review Groups and not by disease or disease state.  The reviewers can thus easily identify multiple grant applications for essentially the same project.  In these cases, application processing may be delayed or the application(s) may be returned to the applicant without review.

Essentially identical applications will not be reviewed except for: 1) individuals submitting an application for an Independent Scientist Award (K02) proposing essentially identical research in an application for an individual research project; and 2) individuals submitting an individual research project identical to a subproject that is part of a program project or center grant application.

Resubmission of Unfunded RFA Applications and Applications with a Changed Grant Activity Code

The majority of grant applications submitted to NIH each year are investigator-initiated.  However, the NIH Institutes and Centers also solicit grant applications on specific topics through the use of Requests for Applications (RFAs), such as the RFA-OD-09-003: NIH Challenge Grants in Health and Science Research (RC1).  Since an RFA often has special considerations of eligibility, scientific scope, and review criteria, unfunded RFA applications may be resubmitted as new applications to another FOA or activity code as long as the application is modified appropriately to fit the application requirements of the new FOA or activity code.  The general policy on application resubmission, stated below, applies to all activity codes that might be solicited via an RFA and to instances where there is a change in activity code.  There may, however, be exceptions to this policy, which will be clearly identified in the original RFA or in a follow-up RFA.

In addition, due to the NIH policy of not allowing submission of, similar, essentially identical, or identical applications, no resubmission under the resubmission policy stated above may occur until after the peer review process is completed and a summary statement has been provided to the applicant.

Special Information for Pending Challenge Grant (RC1) Applications

It is important to note that NIH anticipates a large number of unsuccessful applications after the review of RFA OD-09-003, NIH Challenge Grants in Health and Science Research (RC1).  In accordance with the policies described above, the earliest a new application from that unfunded pool could be submitted is during the Cycle III due dates for new applications (available at (http://grants.nih.gov/grants/funding/submissionschedule.htm).  In addition the following conditions must be met:

Any reconfigured RC1 applications submitted that are found to be not in compliance with these policies will be withdrawn without further consideration.  In particular, any application submitted for Cycle II due dates before the initial review process is complete will be returned.

Inquiries

Questions concerning this Notice should be referred to GrantsInfo@mail.nih.gov.


Weekly TOC for this Announcement
NIH Funding Opportunities and Notices


Office of Extramural Research (OER) - Home Page Office of Extramural
Research (OER)
  National Institutes of Health (NIH) - Home Page National Institutes of Health (NIH)
9000 Rockville Pike
Bethesda, Maryland 20892
  Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) - Home Page Department of Health
and Human Services (HHS)
  USA.gov - Government Made Easy


Note: For help accessing PDF, RTF, MS Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Audio or Video files, see Help Downloading Files.